Obviously Five Believers; understanding the music and lyrics of the Dylan song

There is a quote that Heylin uses and which turns up in lots of other places saying, that the band, at the recording session, made a number of false starts, and Dylan then admonished them saying it was a very easy song.

What no one seems to have picked up on is the fact that it isn’t.  It is downright odd, and if the musicians had not rehearsed it until Dylan’s attempted takes yes it was bound to fall apart.   The morale of the story is, never take Dylan at his word, he could be having you on.

If we were coming to this third side of Blonde on Blonde for the first time we would have noticed that tracks one to four are all marked out by their unusual chord changes.  But here Dylan tricks us again, and instead gives us the chords of the classic 12 bar blues.  It is not the chords that change – it is the whole “12 bar” thing.

The trick to understanding this song is to compare it musically the Muddy Waters “Good Morning Little Schoolgirl” on which Five Believers is based.  (You can also use Memphis Minnie’s “Me and My Chauffeur Blues”)    The Muddy Waters song itself doesn’t fit properly into the 12 bar structure, but Dylan goes further for what we get with “Five Believers” is a ten bar 12 bar blues.  There are eight bars of singing and two bars of instrumental at the end.  No wonder the musicians kept falling over it.

1: Early in the mornin’
2: Early in the mornin’
3: I’m callin’ you to
4 I’m callin’ you to
5: Please come home [6 – instrumental]
7: Yes, I guess I could make it without you
8: If I just didn’t feel so all alone

[9/10] instrumental

Who knows what it means.  Quite honestly, it probably means nothing other than the fact that he wants the woman.  You can go much further than that, but it is all guesswork.

The verse that gives the song its title is the oddest of them all.

Fifteen jugglers
Fifteen jugglers
Five believers
Five believers
All dressed like men
Tell yo’ mama not to worry because
They’re just my friends

The notion has been put that this verse tells us that this is a song about uncertainty, and I will go along with that, not least because I am uncertain about it.  My guess is he just liked the sound of the words, but if you want to take it as fifteen music critics trying to work out the meanings and five fans believing that every song has a secret message, then fine.

Certainly, as we have seen with those who interpret every song as having a Christian message, you can make the meanings work any way you want, if you try hard enough.

Here’s the opening of the “schoolgirl”

Good mornin’ little schoolgirl
Can I go home with you
Tell your mama and your daddy
That I’m a little school boy too

Finally as we can see from the lyrics, the Chauffeur song is closer to Dylan’s approach

Won’t you be my chauffeur?
Won’t you be my chauffeur?
I wants him to drive me
I wants him to drive me downtown
Yes, he drives so easy
I can’t turn him down

But I don’t want him
But I don’t want him
To be ridin’ these girls
To be ridin’ these girls around
So I’m gonna steal me a pistol
Shoot my chauffeur down

Well, I must buy him
Well, I must buy him
A brand new V8
A brand new V8 Ford
Then he won’t need no passengers
I will be his load

Going to let my chauffeur
Going to let my chauffeur
Drive me around the
Drive me around the world
Then he can be my little boy
Yes, I’ll be his girl

Index to all the songs on the site

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Obviously Five Believers; understanding the music and lyrics of the Dylan song

  1. Oh! I had no idea that Dylan’s song is so closely related to “Good Morning Little Schoolgirl!”
    Great comments, but one small error. You counted the song wrong; it’s 20 bars long, not 10. I’d analyze Dylan’s song as a 16-bar blues plus a 4-measure instrumental tag.

  2. TonyAttwood says:

    Charley, it just depends on how you hear it – whether it is a slow 4/4 pulse or a fast 4/4 pulse. Since Dylan never writes his music out we’ll never know – it is just interpretation.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *