- The evolution of Bob’s songwriting through his early compositions and performances
- Bob Dylan and Dada: the song is beautiful, the world is exploding
- Murder Most Foul part 16: One, two, Freddy’s coming for you
By Tony Attwood
My thesis, which as I have suggested recently, is developing as I write these little articles, is that Bob explores themes of interest to him, through writing songs that are related to his current area of interest. Then, having had enough of that he takes a leap onwards and moves into a totally new lyrical arena.
In recent articles I have been looking at the songs written in 1965, and taking them strictly in the order in which they were written (or as close as we can get to that order from the information available).
Now the opening eight songs composed that year were (with my simplistic summary of the lyrics, in brackets)
- Farewell Angelina (Song of Farewell)
- Love is just a four letter word (Is love real?)
- Subterranean Homesick Blues (Beat Poetry as rock music, the artist vs society; Dada)
- Outlaw Blues (Moving on, The artist vs society; Dada)
- Love Minus Zero (Love)
- California (Blues, moving on)
- She Belongs to Me (Love)
- It’s all over now baby blue (Song of Farewell)
Thus we find there were…
- Four songs of farewell and moving on
- Three love songs
- One outlier – a song on the issue of the artist vs society.
Now I admit of course that this is not the same as someone writing love song after love song, but the fact is that I don’t recall any articles about Bob that have pointed these links out, when considering Bob’s work in the order in which he composed the songs.
So it does seem to me that early in 1965, the issues of love and moving on were central to his thinking – which is not something that we can say of other songwriting periods during Bob’s life thus far.
In the previous article we got as far as considering “Outlaw Blues” which now takes us into a group of subsequent compositions in which Bob was able to settle into his selected themes of love and moving on with considerable success, undoubtedly building on the compositional experiences he has had in working on the previous four songs.
“Love minus zero” really is a perfect title for his next song, and one that surely every Dylan fans knows inside out. The woman is perfection; the singer is totally and utterly in love.
But Bob does not give up experimenting even when writing about perfection, for here we have a complete divergence from conventional rhyming in songs. Silence and violence rhyme in lines one and two, but in the next quatrain lines two and three rhyme (hours and flowers)
Next we have lines one, two and three rhyming (bus stations. situations, quotations), but then in the fourth quatrain we have no rhymes (future, softly failure, all).
By the last two sets of four lines the rhyming seems to have vanished completely as the final quatrain offers hammer, rainy, raven, wing, as the four end of line words
The song carries these variations through so that we don’t notice them, and of course Bob may have meant nothing by this – although it is interesting to ponder that he was suggesting that perfect love does not need the closeness that rhyme suggests, because that is already there. You can be your own person (thus speaking your own lines) and yet still be in love.
Moving on (although the subject matter of “She Belongs to Me” is once again love), there is of course the issue that the equality implied in the relationship of “Love Minus Zero” is now missing and ownership has taken over. “She Belongs” is a classic 12 bar blues in lyrical construction, although the chords in the third line of each verse have been varied from the classic norm.
Thus “She Belongs to Me” is even simpler in terms of the music and there is no uncertainty in the message except for the contradiction between the lyrics of the verses – for this woman, as becomes clear as the song progresses, is perfection, and the man is her slave.
So we have two separate visions of love and devotion. In “Love Minus Zero” the woman is worshipped, while in “She Belongs to Me” that title is exactly the opposite of the truth, unless we consider the presents selected in the final verse literally, in which case she does belong to him, because she is a child – despite the fact that Bob tells us in verse three, “She’s nobody’s child” – a statement seemingly contradicted by the notion that she is under age (which in my country is 16, but in other countries this is different), and thus the law can’t touch her.
Either way in both songs, love is at the heart of the matter and as every parent surely has experienced at some time, in the eyes of one’s children, one is simply an antique.
But then Bob ended this set of song writing with his bitter song of farewell, “It’s all over now baby blue”. It makes a fitting end to the year, and represents a strong contrast with the earlier love songs.
I think it is fair to say that nothing on the second side of the album prepares us for “It’s all over now baby blue” which lyrically is so different from the love songs mentioned above. There is no gentility in the lyrics and although the vocal line allows the singer to express anger, the lyrics seem to have more resignation than the traditional shouting “Get Out!” which can accompany the collapse of an affair.
You must leave now, take what you need, you think will last But whatever you wish to keep, you better grab it fast
There is a deep resignation in those lines.
There have been, in popular and folk music, tens of thousands of songs on the topic of lost love, but this is different. Neither party seems to have lost love; it has just all broken down.
Bob clearly had a particular affection for this song as he performed it 632 times across a sixty year period. Yet it is one of the most painful songs Bob has ever composed. Yes it says we can start again (“Strike another match go start anew”) but even so….
It was the last song for the album that was recorded so the title line might refer to that achievement – he had worked for months writing and recording the songs so the album’s creation was all over now, and Bob must have known by then that it did include a number of utter masterpieces, besides this final track. After all the B side alone (which of course we have considered in detail on this site) contained Mr Tambourine Man, Gates of Eden and It’s Alright Ma as well as this track. So with that achievement any creative artist is surely fully entitled to say “it’s all over now”.
But the song, and indeed the album, said far more than this. Yet it was now over, and although Bob continued writing (he composed a total of 31 songs in that year which we know about, and quite probably a few more which were abandoned part way through and destroyed). He did also write some other songs which we all remember within the same year as these songs we have considered so far, but many did not leave a mark as the tracks we have been looking at of late did.
Protest against the world as it was, continued to be a major theme for Bob, notably with With God on our Side, Only a pawn in their game, North Country Blues, but then Bob’s vision seemed to change for suddenly he moved across the songs that brought with them hope rather than despair, particularly with When the ship comes in and The Times they are a-Changing which followed each other in quick succession.
So there were also signs that maybe Bob was thinking that he had taken his protest, or perhaps even his songwriting, as far as he could, as he ended the year with One too many mornings, and Restless Farewell each of which did seem to signify that this really was time to move on to something new.
—————-
