By Tony Attwood
This series on Bob’s early songs has been interspersed by other articles, but as I have realised the theme that is being developed I’ve felt the need to put them in an appropriate order. So if you are interested in the whole theme of how Bob decided what he was going to write about next, and how he did that,, that’s what this has become….
Prelude
- Are Bob Dylan’s songs related to events that happen around him?
- Bob Dylan’s fascination with the notion of change
Bob Dylan exploring new worlds…
- Bob ventures into new themes….
- Bob Dylan at the very top of his abilities as a composer: the start of 1963
- Bob ventures into new themes…. 1963 continued
- Bob Dylan and Dada: the song is beautiful, the world is exploding
Of late it has become clear to me that Bob’s lyrics can be best appreciated (and to a degree better understood) by going back through his compositions and listening to them in the order in which they were written, rather than as isolated monuments, which is how I feel most commentators (certainly including myself) have written about them.
But in now writing about Bob’s lyrics (which is what these articles are primarily about) I am finding connections and relationships between the songs that I was not aware of before.
That of course could be due to my own inattentiveness and lack of focus, but returning to the origins of Bob’s song writing has certainly revealed a lot to me of which I was no aware before.
In my last piece (Bob Dylan and Dada) I dwelt at some length on the song “Farewell Angelina”, and I think it is interesting at this point to consider what Bob wrote thereafter. I mean, if you really think the world is exploding, what do you say next, when, presumably, it hasn’t.
Now of course there have been series before that consider Bob’s compositions in the order in which they were written – but my own impression is that few of these actually note the impact and influence each composition of Bob’s can have on what came next, and what each one can draw from what Bob created previously.
In the case of Farewell Angelina Bob subsequently wrote Love is just a four letter word which in many ways is the antithesis of “Farewell Angelina”. For “Farewell” explores the depths and heights of love in a language that moves away from the everyday and takes us to new dimensions. And it ends with the poet being so utterly overwhelmed that he has to back off. He can no longer stand being in the world of events; all he can do is retreat
Machine guns are roaring Puppets heave rocks At misunderstood visions And at the faces of clocks Call me any name you like I will never deny it But farewell Angelina The sky is erupting And I must go where it's quiet
So the poetic Dylan has seemingly retreated from the world of Angelina – the real world as far as we can tell. But where did he want to go? Indeed where did he go? Was it to somewhere peaceful where he can recover his composure, perhaps quietly drown his sorrows and forget his past?
In fact, no that is not where he went. Not at all. Indeed placing the new composition immediately after the last can be quite a shock
Now as far as this song is about anything, in previous articles, I’ve put it down as “the artist vs society” and in fact when we listen to the next song Bob wrote (Outlaw Blues) that appears to be on the same subject. It certainly has the same level of aggression and a fair degree of justification….
The lyrics of course changed as Bob worked on various recordings of the song, and that initial version above is not how things turned out on the LP but the essence of the song in each version is escape, or perhaps as I described it before, “moving on” with lines such as
- “Ain’t it hard to stumble And land in some funny lagoon?”
“Ain’t gonna hang no picture, Ain’t gonna hang no picture frame”
“Well, I wish I was on some Australian mountain range”
“I got my dark sunglasses I got for good luck my black tooth”
“I got a woman in Jackson I ain’t gonna say her name”
But if we look at the four songs composed by Bob at the start of 1965 we find a real tussle going on. “Farewell Angelina” was that complex mix of emotions – so complex that the singer himself can’t work out what is going on. And if I may be excused the intolerable habit of quoting oneself, what I said was that “Bob was saying ‘farewell’ to the old days, to bourgeois society and to the war. But what he was not doing was telling us his vision of the future.”
So he said farewell with sadness and bemusement (Farewell Angelina) and gentleness (Love is just a four letter word) before he seemed to say, “Enough of this!” and head towards what I have often perceived as a “Dada period” of this work, or if that is going too far, then at least a view of the artist and the society around the artist as two utterly different things.
In such a vision, “Farewell Angelina” really is one of the most beautiful, elegant and sad songs of farewell ever written, and “Love is just a four letter word” is the final “kick it down the road” postscript. So that then, having dealt with love and all it entails, Bob really turns on society and utilises all that Dada can offer. It was Bob’s way of disrupting the traditions of popular music – traditions for which he had no further use, having written the wonderful, beautiful and elegant, “Farewell Angelina”. Thus we now have Subterranean Homesick Blues – as a representation of the artist against society. Here it is from the Never Ending Tour in 2010.
Now after this came Outlaw Blues which seems to me to carry on the same fight between the creative artist who wants eternally to find something new, and his audience who wants to see or hear the best bits of what has gone before. As such, it is the representation of where Bob’s life had got to, and indeed where things still are.
Indeed I find a real connection between “Outlaw Blues” and “Subterranean Homesick Blues” and it is thus no surprise looking back to realise that the two songs were written one after the other. The big difference is that “Outlaw Blues” was only ever played once by Bob in public – and we had to wait until 2007 for that. Subterranean got 120 outings running right through until 2002.
I don’t have a recording of “Outlaw Blues” played by Bob on tour, but multiple people have tried to cover the song – although in my opinion (which of course this always is, until you decide to write an article and send it to me for publication – Tony@schools.co.uk) there was one (but only one) cover version of the song that is really, really, worth noting.
I do hope you have a moment to listen to it.
The Morning Benders get that negativity that runs through some of Bob’s songs at that moment of composition and express it perfectly in my view.
But… and this is the very big point… this was one of those moments where Bob was getting feelings out of his system – and that indeed is exactly what I think The Morning Blenders achieve.
And get it out of his system is exactly what Bob did with this song. For after the four songs of the start of 1965 which said farewell, questioned if love was real, and took us into the wild and chaotic world of Dada….
… suddenly we found Bob had indeed got it all out of his system and gave us another of his astoundingly great works of music and poetry, “Love Minus Zero / No Limit”. Of which I shall say a little more next time – just in case you have a spare moment to read some more.
PS: in case you were running short of time and so didn’t play the track by The Morning Benders, I do hope you might find a moment to come back and listen. It really is worth it.