Bob Dylan’s themes: When the world is not misunderstood – for there is nothing to understand.

 

By Tony Attwood

This is where I get to test my thesis and see if it works.   I have been boldly proposing that there is a way of seeing Bob’s compositions ( at least in his early years as a songwriter) which involves looking at t he songs in terms of them being in groups of themes and subjects.  For my argument is that he would find a theme that interested him, and write maybe three, four or even more songs around that theme, and then move on once more to a new theme.  True some themes simply didn’t work out, but others could become a valuable source of lyrics for half a dozen songs or more.

In each song Dylan would use different musical approaches of course, and obviously different lyrics, but then having written four or five songs involving that theme, he would move on to another theme – perhaps because he was finding this theme just didn’t work musically, or because a new idea popped into his head – or indeed because he felt he had said all he had to say.  He might then come back with one more piece on the earlier theme, but after that he’d be writing from a different point of view.

And I do think “point of view” is the right phrase here, rather than “theme” because Bob wasn’t so much exploring each theme, as rather exploring his own viewpoint.  And the themes varied enormously including (of course) love and lost love (the standard themes of pop and rock) but also moving on, the changes that are happening in the world, etc.

This is not an exact formula of course, Bob’s life, his love affairs, his concerts, his travels and so on would all influence what he wrote about, but this does seem to be a way of considering Bob’s massive output and how he chose which subject to write about.  Of course it doesn’t tell us why he moved on from one theme (for example protesting about a current situation) to another (such as lost love), but still, it is a starting point.  A way of trying to understand why Bob write as he did at any particular time.

And obviously we are dealing with the issue of how Bob felt at the time, what fascinated him, what he saw around him – a whole range of issues that could be influencing him as he chose to write a song on one subject or another.  But I do think we can get something out of this thesis….

In case you would like to trace this theory from its opening (or at least listen to recordings of some of Bob’s compositions from the early 1960s) here are the articles so far…

Bob’s most recent songs by this point had been consumed with the issue of leaving, of moving on, or not being fixed in one place.  It was a theme he picked up from Woody Guthrie and other earlier folk singers, and indeed I quote the line “Strike another match go start anew” as one way of symbolising Bob’s writing at this time.

Indeed one can hardly, as a writer who is seen to be intimately linked to his writing (rather than a writer of fiction that has nothing to do with the writer’s own life) see the songs of 1963 that takes us up to “It’s all over now baby blue,” as anything other than a complete set of “songs of farewell.”

But that raises the question, hat was Bob to write next?   Bob had already had a period of being influenced by Dada.   He’d composed some “songs as farewell” as just noted.   And so he wanted to move on, and at this point he decided to set forth his visions of chaos into a dream format – which of course like virtually all dreams, makes no sense at all.   The only difference here is that Bob extends his dream into 11 verses; more than one can remember from an average dream! Just in case you can’t recall the total lack of connectedness within the next song these four lines should help remind you…

Well, the last I heard of Arab
He was stuck on a whale
That was married to the deputy
Sheriff of the jail

It is probably true to say that no one has written a song quite like this before – or if they have, has not put it on an album.  But what it does do is take the Dada influence on Dylan’s writing, which we have noted in earlier compositions, further still.

Now as I have repeatedly noted, I am writing these little pieces and publishing them as I go, and looking back I see that a few episodes back I called my piece Bob Dylan and Dada: the song is beautiful, the world is exploding – a title that came from the songs I considered in that piece.

And within that article I quoted the line

Machine guns are roaring, puppets heave rocks
At misunderstood visions and at the faces of clocks

and as I write these notes it strikes me again how fundamental those lines are to Bob’s vision at the time.   The lines of course come from the utterly beautiful  “Farewell Angelina” but as we get to Bob Dylan’s 115th Dream  here we are again, except for the fact that the world has moved on

Well, the last I heard of Arab he was stuck on a whale
That was married to the deputy sheriff of the jail

This visions are still misunderstood… except that now there is no understanding to be had.  For now the visions are meaningless.  All is chaos.  It is not that everything is misunderstood, but rather there was nothing to understand in the first place.  It just took a while to understand that!

And just in case we had not all got the message, the next song Bob completed (and please do remember I am considering the songs in the order they were written) opens…

Well, I wake up in the morning
There's frogs inside my socks
Your mama, she's hidin'
Inside the icebox
Your daddy walks in wearin'
A Napoleon Bonaparte mask
Then you ask why I don't live here
Honey, do you have to ask?

The world of course makes no sense, but it can be understood somewhat when taking into account the order in which Bob wrote these songs.  And also, looked at through the simple level of the song titles we find there is an intense love affair, but this breaks up, the world stops making any sense, and even when he’s touring again it still can’t make any sense.

And even at that point Bob was not done.  He knew he was committed to moving on, and his songs would continue to say so, but he still had some more kicking to do – in the sense of directing his kicks at those who he now had no regard for.

Hence the next song was Maggie’s Farm  which manages to combine the themes Bob has been developing.   He is still obviously moving on, but he still sees himself as the artist taking on society and pointing out where everything has gone wrong, and within those lyrics there are elements of Dada too.  We get the idea that no one else understands, but Bob does.

Maggie’s Farm represented the end of this particular journey as Bob was, it feels, now himself very tired of all these battles, as he commented in subsequent songs, which I’ll pick up on next time.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *