Previously in this series
- Bob Dylan in 1963: thinking already, perhaps, it is time to move on….
- Bob Dylan’s themes: When the world is not misunderstood – for there is nothing to understand.
By Tony Attwood
My last two articles in this series, which look at the lyrics of Bob’s early songs, (those composed up to and including 1965), suggested that Bob was seeing himself as an artist (in the broadest sense) in a world that made no sense. Thus the job of the artist was in fact to point out to the society in which he lived, and which we interpret every day as meaningful, is nothing of the kind.
In effect Bob is suggesting that there really was nothing to understand – or maybe as he might say, “nothing is real”. Put another way this view could be expressed in the notion that all of us see the world in our own way, but in each case our “own way” has nothing to do with the reality expressed by others. Those who jog along in the midst of society, see the world around them as the general mass of people do, but a few people (such as Bob himself) are able to step beyond the masses, and see the world and society in different ways and as having different meanings. In short we make sense of the world in order to be able to get from day to day, but in reality there is not much there to make sense of.
As a result each of us can see the world around us in a way that is different from most other people. And I think this really started to take hold of Bob’s thinking and hence his songwriting in 1965, with songs such as On the Road Again, and Maggie’s Farm.
Maggie’s Farm final verse includes the lines…
Well, I try my best to be just like I am
But everybody wants you to be just like them
They say, "Sing while you slave," and I just get bored
These lines, like so many other Dylan lines, can be interpreted in many ways, but for me, “to be just like I am” means for me to react to the world as I see it, while the final line reflects the desire of all societies to hold everyone within their grasp, rather than let anyone express new ideas and thoughts about how, in a totally different scenario, life can be different.
Put briefly, the artist suggests that, “It doesn’t have to be like this,” and that is the biggest challenge any society can face.
And my view is that from this point on, Bob was expressing the view in his songs that as we look out at the world, we see the world as we are expect to see it. Indeed as we have been taught to see it by our parents, our teachers, by newscasts, by newspapers, by broadcasters and so on. But that doesn’t mean that what we see is absolute reality. There is far more to see that what these limited visions don’t take account of.
The title of the next song It takes a lot to laugh it takes a train to cry took this view further and expressed this in its own way. To laugh at the insanity of the world around us takes an enormous amount of strength but really to appreciate just how wrong everything has gone you need even deeper thoughts and awareness.
The second verse of the song does tell us that the world really is ok if only we can look at it in a completely different way…
Don't the moon look good, mama Shinin' through the trees? Don't the brakeman look good, mama Flagging down the "Double E"? Don't the sun look good Goin' down over the sea? Don't my gal look fine When she's comin' after me?
And the final verse tells us Bob wants to share his vision, but if you can’t see the world as such a place of possibilities as he can, then there is nothing much he can do about that.
Now the wintertime is coming The windows are filled with frost I went to tell everybody But I could not get across Well, I wanna be your lover, baby I don't wanna be your boss Don't say I never warned you When your train gets lost
And it was perhaps to rub this point in that Bob recorded various different versions of his next song “Sitting on a Barbed Wire Fence” each with different lyrics all of which suggest that nothing in the world makes any sense, except when you arrange things so it makes sense to you.
Indeed there is some reason to think that in at least one version of this song Bob was laughing at our inability to see what he can see.
I know you're gonna think this song is just a riff Unless you've been inside a tunnel And fell down sixty-nine, seventy feet over a barbed-wire fence
In effect in “Barbed Wire Fence” nothing at all makes sense either physically or mentally. Everything we think we see, everything we think we know, is just how we have put the world together. Nothing is real.