Bob’s relentless drive to expose the self-serving few who are about to fall…

 

By Tony Attwood

Recently in this series…

—————

The thesis of this series of articles I am positing at the moment, is that studying the songs that Bob wrote in the 1960s, in as close as we can get to the exact order in which they were written, helps us understand more about what Bob was saying, or at least implying, in the songs that he wrote.

Bob did not pick topics at random for his lyrics – instead he took topics and then (especially in his early days of composing) explored those topics to see where they took him.  And thus through looking at the lyrics of his songs in the order of composition, we can get an insight into how his thinking was evolving as his fame grew.

And nowhere is this more clear than Bob’s set of explorations about the way people can treat each other – and I suspect (although this point is more of a supposition than the point made above) how people treated him as his fame grew.  Almost everyone who has some success in the arts has started with works that are equivalent to a toddler’s first steps – hesitant, uncertain and ending in a fall.  And Bob remembered what that process was like for him.

This is not to say that thinking along these lines will give us an absolute explanation of what Bob was meaning in each line he wrote, song by song,, but it does give us an insight into where his thoughts were going and how his songwriting was progressing.

If you want to check the order of songs for yourself, they are published here with links to the original reviews of the songs on this site, and generally, a recording or two by way of example.   But here is this series, I am looking to explore Bob’s thinking, as he wrote more and more, and as the appreciation of his work grew and grew.

The last article from this series went under the title When there is nothing to understand then nothing is real and it takes us onto the alarming point that really we don’t know what is going on in the world at all, because a) we try to make sense of everything and b) nothing that we see makes sense.   It’s quite a challenging concept!

And I don’t think it is a concept we can set aside in trying to understand Bob’s message that came through his songs of the later 1960s, for the simple reason that Bob was so insistent in putting it to us in this sequence of songs:

So my view is that Bob was very much pushing his message in one direction: and it was a direction that is quite uncomfortable for many people.  For it proclaims, “nothing makes sense at all.”   And Bob wasn’t finished with this message yet – for the next song continued in the same vein: Sitting on a barbed wire fence

Just the opening verse of this 12 bar blues confirms the point this does not make sense in the conventional notion of the word “sense”

I paid fifteen million dollars, twelve hundred and seventy-two cents
See my hound dog bite a rabbit
And my football’s sitting on a barbed-wire fence

There are a number of versions of the song recorded and the lyrics vary from one to another.  Here’s another

Of course, you’re gonna think this song is a riff
I know you’re gonna think this song is a cliff
Unless you’ve been inside a tunnel
And fell down 69, 70 feet over a barbed-wire fence

… and to me that is saying that really it doesn’t matter what the lyrics are because nothing here is making sense.  The lyrics, in short, are part of the overall sound, and have little to do with the traditional meaning of the words.

But at the same time this gives all of us (all the way from us fans to Bob himself as the composer) because if we have reached the point where nothing makes sense, where do we go next?   Indeed is there a “next” to go to?

In fact, Bob had the answer, by following this up  with the composition of one of his most famous, and as it happens, most complex songs of all: Like a Rolling Stone.  And because this song is so famous, and we all know it inside out, that in itself makes it harder to think back work on understanding the meaning that Bob put into the song.

This is of course the story of a person who once had everything and now has nothing; a reminder to all of us that in the modern world everyone can fall off their tall tower and be reduced to nothing in the blink of an eye.   Particularly song writers!

But as a song it not only benefits from making that message utterly personal – it is clearly pointing a finger at one person – but it asks that most poignant and hurtful question of all, “How does it feel?”

In short, Bob is telling us all that no matter how high and mighty a person can be, she or he can fall, and indeed fall so far that nothing is recoverable.  There is nothing left.

In a very real sense Bob had been writing songs about moving on in the previous weeks and months before “Rolling Stone”. On the Road Again,  Maggie’s Farm,  It takes a lot to laugh it takes a train to cry, Sitting on a barbed wire fence …  but now with the benefit of hindsight we can see that this moving on has been telling us that this was all leading nowhere. “Sitting on the fence” meant nothing, delivered nothing and offered nothing.  It was in fact no more than a prelude to losing everything.

The fence on which she was sitting was not real of course, it was just a view of life the person Bob was singing about had taken up.   Now it is gone.  The fine clothes, the gesture of giving money to the bums, that’s all lost – just as she was warned.

Now of course I am not saying that “Rolling Stone” is an exact sequel to to “Barbed wire fence” but the songs are connected.  The warning was given in the previous song that a fall could happen and it would be a disaster, and now with “Rolling Stone” we are told, it has happened.

But there is still more than that.  Having given the warning, Bob does not feel inclined to give out any help or even sympathy.   Indeed the message is clear and it is viscous, for no sympathy is being offered.  That of course is quite clear from the opening of the chorus with the repeated lin “How does it feel?” but we might also turn to the end of the song

When you ain't got nothing, you got nothing to lose
You're invisible now, you got no secrets to conceal

It is one of the most, if not the most, powerful expressions of “how the mighty have fallen” ever to be found in music, and that in itself makes this work an incredible achievement.   But that achievement becomes much more profound, when we take this song within the context of the way Bob built up to it.

But of course, Bob did not leave it at that.  “Rolling Stone” was and is an utter masterpiece, but Bob was not finished, because just three songs later he explored the consequences of where our society had got to and I shall take a look at that in the next piece in this series.

———————-

 


 

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *