I believe in you

I believe in you.

This overtly religious song has an interesting sub-plot, the issue of rejection, of being the outsider.  It is the theme that every artist (perhaps except Shakespeare and Beethoven) must suffer from at some stage – the rejection by those that don’t quite understand what the hell is going on inside the artist’s head.

So the artist steps back and to sustain his sense of self-belief, has a choice.  Either he gives up, or he continues to believe in what he has done, or he believes in something else which is thought to be guiding him on.

Thus it is with Dylan, who has had many criticisms from questions about the quality of his vocals to his “right” to go electric, from his abandonment of the music of civil rights and revolt to the music of surrealism, to his decision to become a born-again Christian and (following the teaching) to tell the world about it.

What is remarkable about the recording of this song on “Slow Train” is the way in which Mark Knopfler (who was specifically approached by Dylan to play lead on this album) copes with all this.   Brilliantly, is the answer, for it is the guitar work of Knopfler which moves this recording from excellent to stunning.  To the best of my knowledge Knopfler is not an over Christian.

Interestingly the official version of the lyric doesn’t emphasise that this is a religious piece as we have “you” not “You”.  But the consensus is that it is a hymn.

The song is so simple that it could easily not work – it needs the accompaniment to make it happen.  There’s a lovely musical twist too, going to the flattened 7th, the blue chord, on the word “town”.  It is the human approach to the God that is carried by that chordal change.   Dylan says, in that use of the flattened 7th that he is just a regular guy who sings the blues, approaching his new faith.

And they, they look at me and frown
They’d like to drive me from this town
They don’t want me around
’Cause I believe in you

The only element here that gives us the clue that this certainly is a religious song is the end of this first verse, “They’d like to drive me from this town, They don’t want me around, ’Cause I believe in you”   People who are just happy in the friendship and love of others don’t get persecuted.

So it continues…

They show me to the door
They say don’t come back no more
’Cause I don’t be like they’d like me to
And I walk out on my own
A thousand miles from home
But I don’t feel alone
’Cause I believe in you

Everything here could be about another person, not Jesus.  It is just about someone staying with Dylan to sustain him.  But this is the exact opposite of the songs of disdain, so it clearly sounds like a song to his God.

The middle 8 takes us on…

I believe in you even through the tears and the laughter
I believe in you even though we be apart
I believe in you even on the morning after

And then we have the extraordinary change – the sort of change that marks out the brilliant song writer from the ordinary.

Oh, when the dawn is nearing
Oh, when the night is disappearing
Oh, this feeling is still here in my heart

It’s interesting that he should choose these words since a person who believed in himself and the love of friends would never find such times threatening.  Instead the dawn could well be a moment of re-birth and re-affirming of oneself and one’s life.  But it seems, not for Dylan at this time.

From the position of the Christian Dylan has no problem.  But Dylan’s great problem from the position of a militant atheist is that he could not find this security and belief in other people.  He had to turn to a God to find this security, never really knowing that some can do it by themselves.  The swami finds it through a faith in the self – but that seems lacking to Dylan, the supreme artist reaching out for help…

The theme is always the same.

Don’t let me drift too far
Keep me where you are
Where I will always be renewed
And that which you’ve given me today
Is worth more than I could pay
And no matter what they say
I believe in you

And so the ultimate crisis of the converted.  Friends or religion?  Dylan is clear.

Oh, though my friends forsake me
Oh, even that couldn’t make me go back

And one wonders what Dylan’s music would have been like if he had only been able to believe in himself more often.  Clearly he did much of the time, but not always.

Listening to the song and hearing it as a non-religious piece is a revelation in itself.  Just because Dylan meant it as a hymn and a confession doesn’t mean that this is how it has to be.   True, the religiosity is ultimately overwhelming, but as a love song it would be so utterly beautiful.  To have that sung to you would surely be the greatest tribute.

This is the 100th song analysed.  See all the songs in the index.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

1 Response to I believe in you

  1. Johannes Lichti says:

    To the Web Master Mr. Tony Attwood.

    The reason why I came upon this post is because I searched: “Does Mark Knopfer believe in God.” and I got this hit. 🙂 I’ve much appreciated MK for 30 years. I discovered in time that MK was truly instrumental, sorry for the cliche, in BobDylan’s Slow Train Coming Album. I too have not seen evidence that MK is a professing believer in Christ. Saying that, I don’t think he is an ennemy of the cross. I believe Knopfler has a compassionate soul. He has written lyrics that show his admiration of those who in a hostile environment were followers of Christ i.e. Balony Again / Sailing to Philadelphia. I have seen MK serveral times in concerts and also with Bod Dylan in Luxembourg two years ago. Thank you for your fine commentaries. I shall continue to read your posts on bob-dylan.org. JL/Luxembourg

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *